TYLER, TX — A 71-year-old woman was scammed out of $64,000 after allegedly being targeted by two men posing as roofers—one of whom is now behind bars.
According to documents obtained by CBS19, Levy Aaron Lee of Van, Texas, and an accomplice are accused of manipulating the victim into paying nearly four times the cost of a typical new roof for unnecessary “repairs” -most of which they reportedly fabricated themselves.
The incident occurred on March 21, when the suspects showed up at the woman’s home claiming her roof was “unstable.” One of the men climbed onto the roof, jumped up and down, and pointed out soft spots—areas that authorities say they likely damaged to create a false sense of urgency.
A Smith County deputy later examined the roof and described the work as poorly done, with visibly sunken sections and damaged areas loosely covered with shingles.
After the supposed repairs were completed, a reputable third-party contractor visited the home and told the victim the repairs were fraudulent. The “rotted chimney flute” the men claimed they fixed had simply been painted over, and the real damage appeared to be caused by the suspects themselves.
The victim paid the scammers with six checks and $14,000 in cash—totaling $64,000. Investigators say Lee’s partner insisted that all payments be made out to Lee directly.
Levy Aaron Lee was arrested and booked into the Smith County Jail on charges of financial abuse of an elderly person involving $30,000 to $150,000. His bond is set at $350,000. As of now, the second suspect has not been charged.
Homeowner Tip: How to Avoid Roofing Scams
Roofing scams like this one are more common than you might think—especially after storms or in neighborhoods with older homes. Here are a few ways to protect yourself or a loved one:
1. Never trust unsolicited roofers.
If someone knocks on your door claiming you need roof work, be cautious—especially if you haven’t noticed any issues.
2. Always get multiple quotes.
A trustworthy contractor won’t pressure you into making a decision on the spot.
3. Verify credentials.
Check for proper licensing, insurance, and online reviews. Ask for references.
4. Get everything in writing.
Detailed written estimates and contracts protect you. Be wary of vague descriptions like “roof repair” without itemized details.
5. Never pay in full upfront.
Reputable contractors typically ask for a deposit and set payment milestones. Large cash payments are a red flag.
6. Involve a trusted third party.
Especially for elderly homeowners, having a family member or friend present can help avoid making costly decisions under pressure.
