Homeowners choosing a new roof often find themselves overwhelmed by brand options. Eight of the most popular asphalt shingle brands in North America are Atlas, Owens Corning, Tamko, GAF, CertainTeed, IKO, PABCO, and BP (Building Products of Canada). Each offers an array of shingles with promises of strength, style, and security. In this comprehensive comparison, we’ll break down how these brands stack up on all the factors that matter: durability, warranty, pricing, aesthetic variety, ease of installation, and performance in different climates. Our goal is to equip you with engaging yet informative insights so you can make a confident roofing decision for your home.

Atlas Roofing

Atlas is a relatively younger company (founded in 1982) that has rapidly grown into a large shingle manufacturers. Durability: Atlas shingles are built with weather in mind. Their top-tier products, like the StormMaster series, are engineered to endure extreme conditions – StormMaster Shake shingles are rated to withstand winds up to 150 mph and carry the highest Class 4 impact rating for hail. Even Atlas’s more common architectural line, Pinnacle Pristine, offers Class 3 impact resistance, giving it an edge in toughness over many standard shingles. A key durability feature across Atlas lines is the algae resistance: Atlas uses 3M Scotchgard™ Protector on many shingles to prevent those ugly black streaks from algae. In fact, Atlas provides a lifetime algae warranty on Scotchgard-treated shingles, which is the best in the business (most competitors offer around 10–25 years of algae protection). Atlas shingles also come with robust wind warranties (often 130 mph) thanks to their reinforced nailing strip (the “Sweet Spot” nailing area that helps shingles stay put in high winds).

Warranty: Atlas gives a standard limited lifetime warranty on architectural shingles, with an enhanced 15-year period of non-prorated coverage (full replacement cost) out of the gate. For homeowners who install a full Atlas roofing system with a certified contractor, Atlas offers extended coverage (such as a 50-year premium protection that isn’t prorated). In short, Atlas stands behind their product for the long haul, especially when properly installed as a system.

Pricing: Atlas’s offerings run the gamut from affordable to premium pricing. The company produces everything from value-oriented 3-tab shingles to high-end designer shingles. This means budget-conscious homeowners can consider Atlas’s basic lines (like the ProLam series), while those seeking the best of the best can opt for luxury lines that cost more but deliver extra features.

Aesthetic Variety: Atlas knows a roof makes a big impact on curb appeal. They provide a wide array of styles and colors to suit different tastes. For example, the Pinnacle Pristine architectural shingles come in a broad palette of colors, from earthy tones to vivid hues, allowing homeowners to match their roof to their home’s style. Atlas’s designer lines, such as Briarwood Pro and Castlebrook, use high-definition coloration and shading for an upscale dimensional look. Whether you want a classic charcoal gray roof or a bold desert tan, Atlas likely has a shade for you.

Ease of Installation: Professional roofers generally find Atlas shingles straightforward to install. The shingles feature a reinforced nailing zone (Atlas’s “Sweet Spot”) similar in concept to other brands’ nail guides, which provides a clear target and strong hold for each nail. This enhances installation accuracy and helps the roof resist wind uplift. One thing to note is that like many asphalt shingles, Atlas products need proper warm-weather installation to seal optimally. Some contractors have observed that certain Atlas shingles (like the Pinnacle line) can be slower to seal in very cold weather. This just means that if you live in a cold climate, you’ll want to schedule installation in milder weather or trust your roofer to take extra steps to ensure proper sealing.

Climate Performance: Atlas specifically engineers products for tough climates. In storm-prone areas (hurricanes, severe thunderstorms), Atlas’s StormMaster shingles are a compelling choice – their high wind rating up to 150 mph and Class 4 impact resistance mean they can endure intense wind gusts and hail hits without failure. In hot, sunny climates, Atlas offers “Cool Roof” options like the Pinnacle Impact Sun shingles that reflect more sunlight to keep your attic cooler. In humid, algae-prone regions (the streaky-roofed Southeast, for example), Atlas’s lifetime algae warranty stands out, keeping your roof looking new and stain-free for decades. Overall, Atlas is known for weather-resistant features at a reasonable price, making it a favorite for homeowners who prioritize storm durability and clean appearance.

Owens Corning

Owens Corning (OC) is one of the most recognized names in roofing – you might recall their Pink Panther mascot. This Fortune 500 company has been manufacturing building materials since 1938, and their shingles are ubiquitous across the U.S. Durability: Owens Corning shingles are widely respected for their balance of strength and weight. A signature OC feature is the SureNail® Technology: a tough, woven fabric strip embedded in the nailing area of many Owens Corning architectural shingles. This provides a “no-guess” nailing target for installers and greatly resists nail pull-through. The result is a roof that holds tight against high winds and is less prone to the nails tearing out. With proper installation, Owens Corning architectural shingles carry wind warranties up to 130 mph, comparable to the industry’s best. Owens Corning also makes impact-resistant shingles (for example, Duration STORM and Duration FLEX lines) for those in hail country, offering Class 3 or 4 impact ratings. Overall longevity is on par with top brands – expect a well-installed OC roof to protect your home for decades.

Warranty: Like most major brands, Owens Corning provides a limited Lifetime Warranty on their architectural shingles for homeowners. Their standard warranty includes a TruPROtection period (non-prorated) of 10 years, which covers 100% of material defects and labor in that initial period. Owens Corning also recently bolstered their algae resistance coverage – their Shingles with StreakGuard® technology now carry a 25-year algae-resistant warranty Additionally, if you install an Owens Corning roofing system with certified installers, you can qualify for extended warranties (like the System Protection or Platinum Protection warranty), which can provide up to 50 years of coverage on materials and include workmanship coverage as well. OC’s warranty and customer service are often praised; the company is known for producing high-quality shingles at a great price and standing behind them.

Pricing: Owens Corning shingles span all price ranges and styles. They offer inexpensive three-tab shingles (the “Supreme” line) for budget roofs, mid-range dimensional shingles like Oakridge and the hugely popular TruDefinition Duration®, and even a premium designer line (Berkshire® Slate) for those seeking an upscale look. In general, OC’s pricing is very competitive for the quality. Many homeowners find Owens Corning gives a great bang for the buck: you get a durable, well-regarded shingle without paying top dollar, unless you opt for their high-end styles.

Aesthetic Variety: If you have a particular look in mind, chances are Owens Corning has a shingle to match. They provide a large selection of colors and profiles, from the Duration series which comes in vibrant “TruDefinition” color blends, to the designer Berkshire shingles that mimic natural slate. Whether you want a warm brown earthtone roof or a cool gray slate-like appearance, OC has options. Their color science is well-regarded – the depth and contrast in their architectural shingles can add real dimension to a roof. With Owens Corning’s broad catalog, there’s a good chance they have a style and color that fits your home’s design.

Ease of Installation: Owens Corning shingles are considered very installer-friendly. The SureNail strip not only improves durability but also simplifies the roofer’s job by clearly indicating where to nail and by preventing common errors like angled or missed nails. This means fewer chances of installation mistakes that could compromise the roof. The shingles themselves have a good balance of flexibility and stiffness – they’re not too floppy (which could make them hard to lay straight), and not too brittle (which could cause breakage during handling). Many contractors appreciate that OC shingles are readily available at major home improvement stores as well, making logistics easier. If you’re hiring a roofer, you likely won’t hear any complaints about working with Owens Corning materials. When installed correctly, they lie flat and seal well, creating a clean finished look.

Climate Performance: Owens Corning designs its shingles to perform across a variety of climates. In cold and snowy areas, OC roofs hold up well – their shingles have strong fiberglass mats and sealant that keeps them intact through freeze-thaw cycles. (Always make sure they’re installed under the right conditions so the self-seal adhesive can bond properly before the first winter.) For windy regions, standard OC architectural shingles are rated to 130 mph (when installed with the recommended four or six nails), giving good peace of mind in storms. In areas prone to hail, you can opt for Owens Corning’s impact-resistant lines that use polymer-modified asphalt for extra rubbery toughness, helping them absorb hail hits without cracking. And in hot, sunny climates, Owens Corning offers “cool roofing” versions of some shingles (with special reflective granules) that help reduce heat absorption. Also, thanks to that enhanced algae warranty, homeowners in humid or coastal climates can trust OC shingles to resist algae discoloration for a long period. In summary, Owens Corning is a well-rounded choice – it may not have one single gimmick or specialty that stands head and shoulders above others, but it delivers solid performance in virtually every category, which is why it’s one of the top choices for roofs across North America.

TAMKO

TAMKO (headquartered in Joplin, Missouri) is a veteran in the roofing world, manufacturing shingles since 1944. As a brand, TAMKO has built a reputation as a solid, value-focused choice for homeowners. Durability: TAMKO’s product lineup emphasizes dependable performance, especially at the mid-range price point. Their most popular offering is the Heritage® series, a laminated architectural shingle that has been a staple on homes for decades. Heritage shingles are known for their thick cut and distinct color blends, providing good durability and a beautiful dimensional look. TAMKO also introduced the Titan XT™ line of architectural shingles, engineered for enhanced strength – these shingles are designed to resist extreme winds up to 160 mph. A 160 mph wind rating is exceptionally high for asphalt shingles, making Titan XT an attractive option in tornado or hurricane-prone regions. TAMKO’s shingles come with all the expected protections: Class A fire ratings and options with impact resistance for hail (e.g., TAMKO offers the Heritage IR for impact resistance). One thing to note is that TAMKO focuses mostly on standard asphalt technology; unlike some competitors, they do not use fancy rubberized polymers in their regular shingles (though they do have a unique metal shingle line – more on that shortly). Even so, TAMKO asphalt shingles hold up well under normal conditions, offering life spans comparable to other major brands.

Warranty: TAMKO provides a competitive warranty on its shingles, though it may not have as many bells and whistles as some larger brands’ warranty programs. Architectural shingles like Heritage and Titan come with a Limited Lifetime Warranty for homeowners, plus an initial full coverage period (typically the first 10 years for Heritage, which TAMKO calls the “Full Start” period). During that initial period, both materials and labor are covered 100% due to any manufacturing defects. Afterward, the coverage becomes prorated for the remainder of the warranty term (as is standard in the industry). Wind warranty coverage for TAMKO’s architectural shingles generally guarantees up to 110 mph winds (or higher for Titan XT, with its special 160 mph rating). TAMKO also includes algae relief: many TAMKO shingles come with algae-resistant granules and carry an algae cleaning limited warranty (often around 10 years, which helps in humid areas). While TAMKO’s standard warranty is solid, the brand does not have an extensive certified contractor network for extended warranties in the way GAF or CertainTeed do. This means the onus is on choosing a good installer, but once installed, a TAMKO roof is expected to last and the company will stand behind product defects in line with industry norms.

Pricing: One of TAMKO’s strengths is affordability. The brand focuses on the low to mid-tier market, so their shingles often come at a slightly lower cost than equivalent offerings from CertainTeed or GAF. TAMKO’s Heritage architectural shingles, for example, are often priced very competitively, making them a go-to for homeowners who want a reliable dimensional shingle without breaking the bank. On the low end, TAMKO’s Elite Glass-Seal 3-tab shingles are among the more affordable options on the market (suitable for sheds, garages, or tight budgets). On the higher end, something like the Titan XT – with its beefed-up features – will cost more, but still usually less than ultra-premium designer shingles from other brands. In essence, TAMKO gives you a lot of roof for your money, hitting a sweet spot for value-conscious buyers.

Aesthetic Variety: TAMKO understands that homeowners care about curb appeal. The Heritage series comes in a wide selection of vivid shingle colors, often with attractive dual-tone or variegated granule blends. TAMKO’s color palette includes everything from deep rustic reds and weathered wood browns to slate grays and forest greens. They also employ subtle color-tone blending techniques to mimic the look of natural wood shakes or slate, enhancing the dimensional effect on your roof. While TAMKO doesn’t have as many specialty designer shingle profiles as some competitors, they do offer unique options – notably, TAMKO is the only company on this list that manufactures a line of metal shingles. Their MetalWorks line is made of steel and crafted to resemble slate or wood shingles, providing an alternative for homeowners who want the longevity of metal with a classic look. (These are a niche product but worth mentioning as a differentiator.) For asphalt shingle styles, TAMKO sticks to the core categories: three-tabs and architectural laminates. Within those, however, you’ll find plenty of colors to achieve an “authentic and innovative” roof design that suits your home.

Ease of Installation: Professional installers typically find TAMKO shingles user-friendly. There’s nothing radical in the installation process – they follow standard asphalt shingle application methods. Roofers often report that TAMKO shingles have good consistency and lay flat nicely. The Heritage shingles have a reinforced nailing zone (though not a fabric strip like OC’s SureNail), and when nailed properly they have no trouble meeting their wind ratings. TAMKO’s newer Titan XT line likely incorporates some additional reinforcement at the nailing strip to achieve that 160 mph wind rating, meaning the shingles will have a secure hold when installed as instructed. One possible consideration: TAMKO shingles might be slightly lighter-weight than the priciest brands (CertainTeed’s top shingles, for instance), which actually can make them a bit easier to handle and cut on the roof. However, lighter weight can also mean slightly thinner material – a trade-off between ease for the roofer and possibly a bit less heft. Still, ease of installation is a plus for TAMKO; even DIY enthusiasts note that TAMKO shingles are straightforward to work with when doing small structures. As always, for a full home roof, hire a qualified roofer so that the shingle warranty remains valid and you get a professionally finished job.

Climate Performance: TAMKO shingles are built to standard specifications that perform well in varied climates. In moderate climates, you’ll have no issues – a TAMKO roof will shed rain and resist sun damage just as well as other brands. In storm-prone areas, the Titan XT product is specifically designed for extra high wind resistance, which is reassuring for coastal or plains regions with strong winds. For humid, algae-prone climates, TAMKO includes algae-resistant technology in their granules to slow the growth of those dark streaks (they also offer a limited algae warranty, usually around 10 years, to cover excessive discoloration). In hot/sunny climates, TAMKO’s asphalt formulation and UV-resistant granules protect against rapid deterioration – and homeowners can choose lighter colors to reflect more sunlight. TAMKO doesn’t heavily market any “cool roof” compliant shingle in the way some competitors do, but their standard offerings can meet typical needs (and some colors might even be EnergyStar rated; checking specific product specs is advisable if heat is a big concern). In cold climates, TAMKO roofs do fine as long as they’re installed in proper weather. They seal up to become watertight against snow and ice. Just be aware that, like any asphalt shingle, extremely frigid temperatures during installation could make them brittle – timing your install for a warmer day is wise. Overall, TAMKO provides reliable performance across climates, with standout wind resistance on certain products for those who need it. It’s a brand often chosen in areas where budget and decent performance have to balance.

GAF

GAF is North America’s largest roofing manufacturer and one of the most venerable, dating back to 1886. If you ask a roofer to name a shingle brand, GAF will likely be the first words out of their mouth. Durability: GAF’s claim to fame is the Timberline® series, especially the Timberline HDZ – which the company touts as the #1 selling shingle in America. These architectural shingles hit the sweet spot of strength, weight, and cost. Timberline shingles come with a 130 mph wind resistance rating and hold the industry’s top Class A fire rating. GAF uses what they call “Advanced Protection Shingle Technology” in manufacturing, aiming to maximize durability while keeping the shingles from being overly heavy. A notable feature in the HDZ line is the LayerLock™ integration and StrikeZone™ nailing area, which creates a wider nailing target for installers and tightly fuses the shingles to each other. This design leads to excellent wind uplift performance – in fact, GAF offers a special WindProven™ limited wind warranty with no maximum wind speed limit for 15 years when you install a GAF roofing system with Timberline HDZ shingles and the required accessories. That essentially means the shingles are warrantied even in extreme wind events, provided they were installed to GAF’s system standards. For homeowners in hail-prone regions, GAF makes impact-resistant versions like the Timberline AS II (an SBS polymer-modified shingle) and the Armorshield II, both of which achieve Class 4 impact ratings for top-tier hail protection. Going to the other extreme, GAF’s Marquis WeatherMax and Royal Sovereign lines (their 3-tab shingles) are more entry-level and not as thick, but even those have decent wind ratings (60–80 mph for 3-tabs) and serve well on low-budget projects or simpler structures. At the high end, GAF offers “designer” shingles (Camelot®, Grand Sequoia®, Grand Canyon®, etc.) that are heavier and ultra-durable, emulating wood shakes or slate tiles while providing long life. In short, GAF has proven durability across the board, from basic to luxury – and a track record to back it up.

Warranty: GAF provides a tiered warranty system. All GAF Lifetime shingles (basically any architectural or designer shingle, and even their top 3-tab) come with a Lifetime Limited Warranty on manufacturing defects for the original homeowner. This includes 10 years of non-prorated coverage (the “Smart Choice Protection Period”) out of the box. GAF distinguishes itself with several enhanced warranty options if you install a full GAF roofing system (shingles plus at least 3-4 qualifying GAF accessories like underlayment, starter strips, ridge cap, etc.) through a certified contractor. For example, the GAF System Plus warranty extends the non-prorated period to 50 years (material defects), and the coveted Golden Pledge warranty (available through GAF Master Elite contractors) adds up to 25 years of workmanship coverage on top of material coverage. GAF also includes specific coverages like the Algae Resistance Limited Warranty (typically 10 years on standard shingles with StainGuard, and 25 years on those with the newer StainGuard Plus formula used in some HDZ variants). Additionally, as mentioned, GAF’s WindProven™ warranty is an industry-first that offers 15 years of coverage with no wind speed limit (when the full system is installed) – a big plus for hurricane zone homeowners. In summary, GAF’s standard warranty is comparable to its peers, but its upgraded warranties are among the strongest, reflecting the company’s confidence in their shingles when installed as part of their integrated roofing system.

Pricing: GAF covers a broad price spectrum, ensuring there’s a product for every budget. At the low end, the three-tab Royal Sovereign is one of the most affordable shingles from any major brand – you can often find it at big box stores for a very low cost per bundle. Moving up, the Timberline series is mid-range in price and one of the reasons it’s so popular is that it delivers premium quality at a reasonable cost. Many homeowners find Timberline is just a bit more expensive than cheaper competitors but offers better curb appeal and peace of mind, making it a high-value choice. On the premium end, GAF’s designer shingles can get pricey (approaching the cost of CertainTeed’s luxury lines), but they’re still generally slightly less expensive than the absolute top-tier luxury shingles of some competitors. GAF’s economy of scale as the largest manufacturer often helps keep their prices competitive. Also, since GAF products are widely stocked (available at many local lumber yards and home centers), you might benefit from less shipping cost or bulk discounts in some areas. In essence, GAF gives homeowners options across all price points, with the Timberline architectural shingles hitting the sweet spot for most.

Aesthetic Variety: Being such a large company, GAF doesn’t skimp on style choices. For a classic suburban look, the Timberline architectural shingles come in a wide array of colors – from weathered wood browns to driftwood grays, deep charcoal, hunter green, and even rich reddish tones. They have subtle shadow lines that create a pleasing dimensional effect on the roof. If you want your roof to really stand out, GAF’s Designer series offers unique profiles and shapes. For example, Grand Sequoia and Grand Canyon shingles have extra-large tabs and a rugged wood-shake appearance, Camelot II shingles have an elegant cut that mimics old-world slate tiles, and there’s even the Monaco shingle that resembles a Mediterranean clay tile shape. These give high-end curb appeal while still being asphalt. GAF also provides specialty colors in some lines – the Timberline HDZ, for instance, has a selection of “American Harvest” colors which mix extra accent granules for a vibrant look, and their Ultra HD line offers deeper shadow for more drama. Additionally, GAF addresses the modern trend of solar innovation with options like the DecoTech integrated solar shingles (though that’s beyond the asphalt realm). In summary, as a homeowner you’ll find that GAF likely has a shingle style to match your architectural taste, whether it’s simple or elaborate. And because GAF is so widely used, you can often see examples of their colors and styles on homes in your area, which helps in the decision-making.

Ease of Installation: GAF shingles are generally a hit with roofing contractors. The StrikeZone™ nailing area on Timberline HDZ is one reason – it’s an extra-wide nailing strip that GAF designed so that each shingle has a large target for nail placement. This makes it easier for roofers to install shingles correctly (even if a roofer is very skilled, wider targets mean speedier installation and fewer chances of “missed” nails or partial hits). The LayerLock™ feature on HDZ also helps the shingles mechanically fuse together at the overlap, which can simplify the installation and add strength. GAF’s shingles come with good adhesive strips; roofers often comment that GAF shingles tend to seal quickly when the sun hits them, which is great for wind resistance. Because GAF is so common, most roofers have lots of experience with them – so they know the little tricks to make a GAF roof look its best (like using GAF’s starter shingles and ridge cap shingles to ensure the whole system works together nicely). Another installation perk is availability: since you can find GAF at many Home Depot and Lowe’s stores, if a roofer runs short a few bundles or a homeowner needs an extra bundle for a future repair, it’s usually easy to get the identical shingle. If we consider DIY ease, a handy homeowner might use GAF 3-tabs for a shed or small project sourced from a home store; the instructions are clear and the product is forgiving enough for small-scale jobs. Of course, for your home’s main roof, professional installation is recommended, but from an installer’s perspective, GAF is a well-liked brand to work with. The consistent quality control means fewer defective shingles in the batch, which also smooths the job. All these factors contribute to GAF’s reputation as a contractor-friendly brand, which benefits you as the homeowner with a smoother installation and a reliable roof.

Climate Performance: Given their huge market share, GAF shingles are literally on homes in every climate of North America, from the scorching Arizona desert to the frigid Canadian prairies. This real-world presence has proven that GAF roofs can handle it. In cold climates, GAF’s asphalt formulation is crafted to stay flexible enough for proper sealing during the installation season, and once sealed, the shingles stay intact through freeze and thaw cycles. (For extremely cold areas or winter installs, GAF also produces specialized cold-weather application guidelines and their SBS-modified Timberline AS II shingles remain pliable in lower temps for easier installation.) In hot climates, GAF shingles hold up well under intense sun; their UV-resistant granules and fiberglass base help prevent rapid degradation. GAF even offers several shingles that meet cool roof standards (in lighter colors with high reflectance) for energy savings in hot regions. In wet and humid climates, many GAF shingles come with StainGuard® algae protection to slow the growth of algae that cause black streaks. GAF’s StainGuard Plus (on some HDZ colors) is a 25-year algae warranty formula, making them a strong candidate for Gulf coast or southern homes where humidity and algae are a challenge. When it comes to storms, we’ve highlighted the wind and hail features: GAF roofs can be built to the highest wind zones when using their system (with standard architectural shingles rated 130 mph and enhanced coverage for higher winds with WindProven™ when applicable). In hurricane zones, many contractors trust GAF because of that no max wind warranty option – it’s a confidence booster. For hail, the availability of Class 4 impact lines means homeowners in hail alley (parts of the Midwest, for example) can choose a GAF shingle that may qualify for insurance discounts due to its impact toughness. Summing up, GAF has a versatile performance record; it may not specialize in one particular climate extreme (some might argue other brands have slight edges in niche areas), but it performs admirably in virtually all conditions, which is exactly what you’d expect from the country’s leading shingle maker.

CertainTeed

CertainTeed is often regarded as the premium benchmark in the asphalt shingle industry. Based in Pennsylvania and manufacturing since 1904, CertainTeed has a long history of making high-quality building products. Durability: CertainTeed shingles are known for being heavier and thicker than many competitors’ products, which often translates to excellent longevity and strength. If you pick up a CertainTeed Landmark shingle in one hand and a typical budget shingle in the other, you’ll feel the difference. This heft means CertainTeed’s products hold up exceptionally well to the elements. For example, the Landmark architectural shingle (their flagship dimensional product) is a multi-layer laminate that carries a Class A fire rating and built-in algae resistance. Homeowners often report their CertainTeed roofs last well beyond the 20- or 30-year mark when properly ventilated and maintained. The brand’s top-tier luxury shingles – like Presidential Shake, Grand Manor, and Carriage House – are even more robust, some being triple-layered or otherwise engineered for maximum thickness and shadow lines. These not only look beautiful (mimicking wood shakes or slate) but can endure rough weather year after year. CertainTeed shingles typically have wind ratings of 110 mph out of the package, and with enhanced installation (extra nails or special starter/ridge products) they can reach 130 mph wind warranties, which is standard for the industry’s architectural shingles. CertainTeed also offers impact-resistant versions of some lines (like Landmark IR) for extra protection in hail zones. In terms of pure durability and materials quality, CertainTeed often ranks at the top, which is why many contractors and homeowners see it as a “you get what you pay for” scenario – a bit more cost, but potentially more years of service.

Warranty: CertainTeed backs its shingles with some of the best warranty terms in the business. All their lifetime shingles (Landmark and up) come with a Lifetime Limited Warranty for the original owner, and importantly, they include a SureStart™ protection period on most shingles (typically the first 10 years for an architectural shingle) where they cover 100% of materials AND labor if the product fails due to manufacturing defect. This is a strong initial protection, giving you full reassurance for that critical first decade. After that, the warranty becomes prorated for the remaining years. CertainTeed’s higher end products may have even longer SureStart periods or specific guarantees (for instance, some premium lines might offer 15 years before proration – it varies, so checking the warranty for your chosen product is wise). The company also provides algae resistance warranties, generally around 10 or 15 years depending on the shingle, to cover excessive staining. One advantage with CertainTeed is that even their 3-tab shingles (like the XT25) have decent warranty terms (often 20 or 25-year, whereas some competitors only give 5-year full coverage on basic lines). Additionally, if you go through a CertainTeed-certified contractor, you can access extended warranty packages such as the SureStart PLUS, which can extend coverage (including workmanship) for 20 or 50 years depending on the level chosen. In short, CertainTeed’s warranty structure reflects their confidence in their product – and indeed they boast “one of the best guarantees in the business”. Do keep in mind, as with any brand, warranties have requirements (proper installation, ventilation, etc.) and some homeowners have noted CertainTeed can be strict on warranty claims (because they often conclude issues are installation-related). This just underscores the need to have a reputable installer. If you do, you’ll have a roof with top-notch protection and a warranty to match.

Pricing: CertainTeed is generally on the higher end of the price scale.  They have some entry-level products but also some of the most expensive asphalt shingles on the market (their premium designer lines). For an apples-to-apples comparison at the architectural level: CertainTeed Landmark shingles usually cost a bit more per square (per 100 sq. ft.) than, say, GAF Timberline or Owens Corning Duration. Many roofing pros and consumers feel this premium is justified by the heavier weight and perceived quality of Landmark. When you step up to products like **Presidential Shake®**, which is a luxury asphalt shingle that imitates hand-split wood shakes, the cost climbs further (but still far cheaper than real cedar or slate roofing). These high-end shingles can be in price rating, often appealing to homeowners in upscale neighborhoods or those who simply want the most distinctive roof on the block. The takeaway on cost: if you’re budget-sensitive, CertainTeed has options like the XT 3-tabs or the Landmark (their “standard” architectural line) which are competitively priced, though not the cheapest. If you’re willing to invest more for a premium roofing appearance and potentially longer life, CertainTeed’s top-tier lines offer those benefits at a higher cost. Essentially, CertainTeed caters to the quality-conscious segment of the market, and you’ll see that reflected in pricing.

Aesthetic Variety: CertainTeed shines when it comes to aesthetic options. They offer an expansive array of designs, colors, and textures. For those wanting a natural look, the landmark** Landmark series itself comes in several variants – Landmark, Landmark Pro, Landmark Premium, each with richer thickness or better fades as you go up. Then you have Highland Slate, which mimics slate tiles, Presidential Shake and its luxury upgrade Presidential Shake TL (Triple-Laminate) that convincingly imitates wood shakes in a dimensional asphalt form. CertainTeed’s Grand Manor and Carriage House shingles are among the most eye-catching asphalt shingles available, featuring extra depth and unique cut-outs that give a scalloped or diamond-pattern effect reminiscent of old-world slate roofs. Color selection is broad too. CertainTeed offers everything from subtle black and gray tones to blended colors like Weathered Wood, Colonial Slate (which mixes dark gray with hints of red and blue), or unique shades like Hunter Green or Heather Blend. Because they have such a diverse portfolio, you can find a shingle to complement historic homes, modern homes, and everything in between. Even their plain three-tab XT25 shingles come in a nice array of colors for those sticking to basics. Importantly, CertainTeed’s thicker shingles have deep shadow lines and multiple layers, which create a play of light and shadow on the roof that many homeowners find very attractive – it’s a big reason people splurge on those styles. If your goal is a stunning roof that elevates your home’s curb appeal, CertainTeed will give you plenty of choices to achieve that vision.

Ease of Installation: There’s a saying among some roofing contractors: “CertainTeed makes great shingles – you just have to know how to install them correctly.” Because CertainTeed shingles are often heavier and stiffer (especially the luxury lines), they can be a bit more demanding to install. A roofer who is used to thinner, lighter shingles might need to adjust technique due to the weight. However, experienced roofers typically don’t have issues; in fact, many like working with CertainTeed because the shingles are consistent and less likely to tear or scuff during installation due to their toughness. One aspect to consider: heavier shingles may require a bit more effort to lift and position, so a roof job with CertainTeed could take slightly longer or require a more robust crew – a minor point usually. CertainTeed doesn’t have a fancy fabric nailing strip like Owens Corning, but they do often double-layer the nailing zone on laminated shingles for added strength. Installers just need to follow the alignment guides and nail as specified (typically 4 nails per shingle for standard wind, 6 nails for high-wind areas). The triple-layered products (Presidential TL, etc.) require careful alignment due to their unique cuts, but the company provides instructions and shingle layout diagrams to aid roofers. If you hire a roofer who is familiar with CertainTeed (many are, given the brand’s long-standing presence), you should get an excellent result. DIY installation of CertainTeed is not commonly attempted – these are premium shingles and usually put on by pros. Another practical aspect: because of their weight, verify your roof structure is solid (which it likely is, but very old or marginal roof decks should be checked) – this is typically not an issue unless you were borderline on structural load to begin with or adding multiple layers. All in all, while not the simplest or lightest to handle, CertainTeed shingles reward a proper installation with a beautiful and enduring roof. Most contractors who pride themselves on quality love using CertainTeed.

Climate Performance: CertainTeed’s robust build makes it a champion in tough climates. In regions with heavy snowfall or long winters, the durability and weight of CertainTeed shingles can be beneficial – they can withstand the weight of snow and ice and are less prone to cracking in cold weather due to their thickness (though like any asphalt roof, proper ventilation and perhaps an ice & water shield underlayment at eaves are key in such climates). In extremely hot climates, a heavier shingle can also mean a bit more mass to absorb and re-radiate heat, and CertainTeed does offer reflective “Cool Roof” versions in some lighter colors to meet energy codes in places like California. For wind, properly installed CertainTeed roofs handle high winds well; their shingles have been tested and rated up to 110/130 mph, and many roofers will attest that these shingles seem to stay put during storms when others might not. CertainTeed’s impact-resistant shingles (like NorthGate or the IR versions of Landmark) use rubber-like modifiers or extra layers to earn Class 4 ratings, which is great for hail-prone areas. In humid, algae-prone regions, CertainTeed includes algae-resistant granules in products like Landmark (which is advertised as algae-resistant). They typically offer 10-year algae stain warranties on those. So your beautiful driftwood gray roof is less likely to develop black streaks prematurely. It’s worth noting that in the past, CertainTeed had lines of organic-base shingles that did not fare well in harsh climates, but those are long discontinued; all modern CertainTeed shingles use fiberglass mats and improved asphalt. Today’s lineup is engineered to endure harsh weather for decades, which is why you often see CertainTeed specified in high-end homes or in regions where homeowners demand top performance. Whether it’s the muggy summers of the Deep South or the gale-force winds of the Great Plains, a correctly installed CertainTeed roof is equipped to protect your home in style.

IKO

IKO is a global roofing manufacturer with roots in Alberta, Canada, and they’ve leveraged that cold-weather expertise into making shingles that can take a beating. IKO shingles might not have the same name recognition in the U.S. as GAF or Owens Corning, but they are a major player and particularly common in Canada and parts of the northern U.S. Durability: IKO’s philosophy centers on building shingles to survive harsh weather. They have several lines designed for toughness. For example, the IKO Nordic™ architectural shingle is made extra thick and strong, achieving a Class 4 impact resistance (the highest level) and a wind rating of 130 mph. Nordic shingles use a fortified asphalt and come with the ArmourZone® reinforced nailing strip, which gives a wider nailing area and extra tear strength. Similarly, the IKO Dynasty™ line also has the ArmourZone feature and is formulated to stay put in high winds, offering that 130 mph wind warranty as well. These shingles are designed to “stay down” and resist uplift even in rough storms. IKO’s heavyweight Crowne Slate is a luxury shingle that mimics real slate and is built to withstand heavy snow loads and severe weather. On the durability front, one could say IKO doesn’t skimp on material – their shingles tend to be on the heavier side in their class (Cambridge, their standard architectural, is competitive in weight with OC Duration and Timberline HD). That said, in past years IKO had some mixed reputation around durability, largely stemming from older product lines or specific issues with shingles manufactured in certain decades. However, their modern fiberglass shingles have improved formulations. They also incorporate algae-resistant granules (often with copper content) to protect roofs in humid climates. All in all, IKO’s top products are built to take on Mother Nature, aligning with the company’s Canadian origins where roofs see extreme cold, wind, and hail.

Warranty: IKO, like others, offers a limited lifetime warranty on their architectural shingles for the original homeowner. The standard IKO warranty usually includes a full coverage period (e.g., the first 15 years non-prorated on a product like Nordic, though it can vary by product). Wind warranty terms will depend on the shingle – many IKO architectural shingles have a 110 mph standard wind warranty, which can often be upgraded to 130 mph when you use extra nails or IKO’s recommended installation method (Nordic and Dynasty are 130 mph out of the box with standard nailing). IKO also provides an algae-resistant warranty (typically around 10 years, which is common, though some of their premium algae-resistant shingles might offer longer). One thing to note is that IKO’s warranty details historically have been seen as somewhat less generous or more pro-rated compared to, say, CertainTeed’s. They may not have as comprehensive of an extended warranty program for certified installers – IKO does have a “ShieldPro Plus” contractor program with some extended warranty options, but it’s not as widely marketed as the GAF or Owens Corning programs. In terms of consumer perception, IKO has sometimes been rated a bit lower on customer satisfaction, which might be due in part to warranty service experiences (or the legacy of older shingle issues). However, for a current homeowner, what matters is understanding the coverage: ensure your installer registers your warranty if required and installs to IKO’s specifications. IKO warranties are transferable once, usually within the first few years, which is a nice feature if you sell your home. While IKO might not boast the very longest non-prorated period in the industry, they do stand behind their products similarly to others. If you have their Class 4 impact shingles, also check with your insurer – IKO’s impact-rated shingles could qualify you for insurance discounts in some areas (not a warranty point, but a durability-plus that saves money).

Pricing: One place IKO often competes aggressively is on price. In many regions, IKO Cambridge (their mainline architectural shingle) is priced a bit lower than flagship products from CertainTeed or GAF. This makes IKO a popular choice for homeowners who want a dimensional shingle look but are on a tighter budget. The cost savings can sometimes be significant on a whole roof. Even IKO’s premium lines like Nordic or Dynasty, with all their upgrades, often come in at or slightly below the cost of similar “impact-resistant” or high-wind shingles from competitors. This value aspect is one of IKO’s selling points: you get high performance specs (130 mph wind, Class 4 hail, etc.) often at a fraction less cost. Of course, the very high-end Crowne Slate will be expensive – any designer shingle is – but IKO doesn’t have as many ultra-premium products as some competitors. Another reason for favorable pricing is that IKO has manufacturing plants in various parts of the U.S. and Canada, which can reduce transportation costs, especially in the central and northern U.S. If you live in an area where IKO is readily available, you might find that the cost per square is a bit friendlier than the “big three” (GAF, OC, CertainTeed). Always compare locally, as prices vary, but know that IKO positions itself as a high-value option: solid quality for a fair price.

Aesthetic Variety: IKO provides a wide range of styles and colors, albeit with perhaps a slightly more traditional slant. Their core architectural shingle (Cambridge) comes in many color blends that complement common home colors – earthy browns, classic black, gray, dual black (their term for a mix of black tones), weathered wood, etc. They also have bold colors like Harvard Slate (a gray with blue undertones) or Driftwood. In total, IKO’s color selection is comparable to others in standard lines. Where IKO shines is that their shingles often have high-definition color blending, giving a pronounced contrast that can look fantastic from the curb. The Dynasty line, for example, introduced some vibrant colors like Emerald Green and Glacier (a cool bluish gray) to cater to homeowners wanting something a little different. IKO’s Crowne Slate designer shingle provides an elegant slate-like appearance with deep shadow lines; it’s offered in a limited but refined color set to mimic stone. One minor con noted by some is that a few IKO lines historically had fewer color choices than, say, CertainTeed Landmark (which has a massive color lineup). For instance, IKO Nordic might not have as many color options (and Roofmaxx noted “fewer color blends” as a con for one IKO product). However, IKO has been expanding options over time. Another aesthetic point: the granule size and shine. Some homeowners notice that IKO shingles have a particular sheen or look to their granules, which can be an aesthetic preference (some love it, some might not notice at all). Overall, IKO offers plenty of aesthetic flexibility for the average homeowner. They might not have as many exotic designer profiles as CertainTeed or GAF (no scalloped Victorian-style asphalt shingle in IKO’s lineup, for example), but they cover the key styles: three-tabs for a traditional look, architectural shingles for the dimensional look, and a slate-look luxury shingle for high-end projects. If your home’s style calls for a reliable, attractive roof without needing ultra-fancy patterns, IKO’s selection will satisfy that need.

Ease of Installation: IKO shingles generally install similarly to other major brands’ shingles, especially the standard architectural ones. Roofers familiar with asphalt shingle techniques will find no big surprises. The introduction of the ArmourZone® reinforced nail strip on products like Dynasty and Nordic has been a plus for installation – this feature provides a 1-1/4 inch wide nailing area with a tough reinforcement, making it easier to hit the sweet spot and helping nails hold even if placed slightly off-center. This not only improves wind performance but also gives installers confidence that the shingles are fastened securely. Many contractors appreciate this, as it resembles other brands’ enhanced nailing features. Historically, some roofers had reservations about IKO because of reports that older IKO shingles could be a bit brittle in cold weather or that the sealant didn’t tack down as fast in cooler climates. IKO has worked on these issues, and current products are designed to seal properly in the appropriate temperature range (usually 40°F and above, like most asphalt shingles). In very cold installations, any shingle can crack if handled roughly, but IKO’s Class 4 lines, for example, use polymer-modified asphalt which stays flexible longer, aiding cold-weather installation. On the roof, IKO shingles cut and handle much like any quality shingle. One possibly unique aspect is that IKO’s large exposure shingles (those that show more surface area) might require care in alignment, but that’s standard procedure for roofers. As far as availability – in Canada and Northern US states, IKO is widely available, so roofing crews often have experience with them. In other areas, you’d want to be sure your roofer is comfortable with IKO, but given their similarity to other brands, this is rarely an issue. In summary, installing an IKO roof is straightforward for pros; with features like ArmourZone aiding the process, an IKO roof can be put on just as smoothly as any other, resulting in a neat, tight roof. Always ensure you use an installer who adheres to the manufacturer’s instructions (this applies to all brands) to get the best performance.

Climate Performance: As a company that started in the chilly climates of Canada, IKO has made sure their shingles perform when the weather gets rough. In cold climates, IKO shingles are formulated to resist crackling in the cold and to survive heavy snow loads (especially the Crowne Slate, which is built with cold, snowy winters in mind). Many IKO shingles, including Cambridge and Dynasty, have been tested in freeze-thaw conditions and they remain reliably sealed and intact. Of course, proper attic ventilation is key to any shingle’s longevity in cold areas (to avoid ice dams), but that aside, IKO roofs in places like the Canadian Rockies or Upper Midwest USA have proven their mettle. In windy areas, we’ve emphasized that IKO’s use of wide nailing zones and thick construction yields wind ratings of 130 mph on their top lines. You can install IKO shingles with confidence in coastal or high-wind regions, knowing they meet the same wind standards as other top brands. For hail, IKO deliberately offers several Class 4 impact options (Nordic, Dynasty, etc.), which not only survive hail better but can give homeowners peace of mind and possibly insurance perks. These are particularly popular in hail-prone provinces and states (like Alberta or Texas). In hot climates, IKO might not be the first brand that comes to mind, but they do perform well under sun exposure too. Their asphalt is refined and the granules provide UV protection; some of their shingles, like the Cambridge Cool Colors series, are designed to meet cool roof requirements in hot/sunny regions by reflecting more sunlight. IKO being a “northern” company doesn’t mean they can’t handle the south – plenty of homes in the southern U.S. have IKO roofs that handle intense sun and heat without issue. In humid climates, IKO includes algae-resistant granules in most products, which helps keep roofs cleaner longer (though some might note that IKO’s algae warranty terms could be shorter than a couple of other brands – typically around 10 years). So if you live in, say, the Southeast U.S., an IKO roof with AR (algae-resistant) granules will fight off those black streaks for a good stretch of time before requiring a gentle cleaning. To sum up, IKO has positioned its shingles as all-weather warriors, with particular strengths in battling cold, wind, and hail. They might not have the same market dominance in the U.S. sunbelt as GAF or OC, but they are certainly capable of sheltering a home in any North American climate. Choosing IKO may come down to the value and performance features you want, especially if you’re in an area with severe weather swings.

PABCO Roofing Products

PABCO may not be a household name across all of North America, but it has a loyal following, especially in the Western United States. Founded in 1984, PABCO Roofing is a smaller, family-owned shingle manufacturer based in Tacoma, Washington. Despite its size, PABCO offers a full line of asphalt shingles and has some unique offerings that help it stand out. Durability: PABCO focuses on producing high-quality, mid- to high-end shingles that can hold up over time. All of PABCO’s laminated architectural shingles come with a limited lifetime warranty, which indicates the company’s confidence in their durability. Their product lineup starts with PABCO Premier®, an architectural shingle that is the most affordable in their range but still comes with that lifetime warranty and a sturdy build. Stepping up, they have PABCO Prestige® (a thicker laminate) and the top-of-the-line Paramount Advantage®. The Paramount Advantage is a heavyweight, ultra-thick shingle with an open-tooth design that creates deep dimensionality and improved strength. It’s designed for homeowners who want a super-durable roof with a unique look – this shingle is thicker for better durability and can handle tough weather while imitating the look of a wood shake with its bold cut profile. PABCO also has a special niche product called PABCO Cascade®, which is a one-of-a-kind diamond-shaped asphalt shingle that gives a historic, Victorian-era pattern on the roof. While Cascade is often chosen for its look (more on that in aesthetics), it’s also built durable, as you’d expect from any laminated shingle. In terms of weather resistance, PABCO shingles are manufactured to meet the needs of the Western climate – heavy rains, occasional snow, and wind. They even produce a solar reflective shingle called PABCO Radiance® for hot, sunny climates, which helps reduce heat absorption by reflecting more sunlight. So whether it’s resisting moss in the Pacific Northwest or sun in the Southwest, PABCO aims to deliver durability that rivals the bigger brands. Their products have Class A fire ratings (important in wildfire-prone west regions) and their heavier shingles boast high wind ratings (typically 110 mph standard, often up to 130 mph with enhanced nailing, similar to others). PABCO might not advertise impact ratings as much, but given their construction, some lines could qualify for Class 3 or 4 impact resistance (checking their spec sheets would confirm). In essence, PABCO’s smaller catalog is curated for quality – they don’t make a super-cheap shingle, instead they start at a higher quality level and go up from there.

Warranty: PABCO provides competitive warranties on its shingle lines, aligning with the industry norm of lifetime coverage on laminated shingles. Purchasing a PABCO Premier roof gets you a Lifetime Limited Warranty on the shingles (for the original owner), which includes a non-prorated period (often the first 10 years full coverage on materials, possibly longer on higher lines). Because PABCO emphasizes the upper-tier market, even their “entry” architectural shingle is treated like a premium product in warranty terms. The exact warranty details can vary by product tier – for example, the top-tier Paramount Advantage may come with a longer full coverage period or additional perks. PABCO also offers algae resistance warranties on shingles that have AR (algae-resistant) granules. In the Northwest, algae and moss can be an issue, so this is important; PABCO’s AR shingles likely have around 10 years of algae warranty, meaning they’ll stay streak-free for at least that long in humid areas. Additionally, PABCO likely has a transferability clause allowing one transfer of the warranty to a new homeowner (if sold within a certain time, like 5 or 10 years). They might not have a huge certified contractor network for extended warranties as a smaller company, but often the base warranty is strong enough to satisfy customers. Importantly, because PABCO is smaller, some homeowners appreciate a more personal touch – though that’s anecdotal, one might find that dealing with warranty claims can sometimes be a bit more direct. We should note that PABCO being confident enough to put lifetime warranties even on its least expensive laminated shingle speaks to their commitment to durability and customer assurance. As always, be sure to register the warranty if required and install according to their specs to enjoy full coverage.

Pricing: PABCO’s price range is average. Generally, a PABCO Premier roof will cost about what a mid-range or slightly above mid-range architectural shingle from a bigger brand would cost. Since PABCO doesn’t make a cheap 3-tab for widespread retail, you’re getting at least an architectural quality, and that carries a corresponding price. The Premier and Prestige lines will be in the $$ to range depending on the market. The unique Cascade shingle might be priced a bit higher due to its specialty nature (and possibly extra labor to install the pattern). The Paramount Advantage, being a beefy luxury shingle, will be at the upper end ($$$). Compared to CertainTeed or GAF’s luxury shingles, PABCO’s might be similarly priced or maybe slightly less, but it’s still a premium. If you’re on the West Coast, one advantage might be that PABCO, being locally produced (in Washington state), could have lower freight costs to West Coast states, sometimes making them a cost-effective premium choice versus, say, shipping in CertainTeed from across the country. However, PABCO’s smaller scale could also mean less economy of scale, potentially making them not “cheap.” Overall, you’d choose PABCO not to save a ton of money upfront, but to get a unique or high-quality product at a fair price. If anything, you might save by getting top-tier performance at a mid-tier price, since even their baseline is high quality. It’s a classic case of a smaller brand carving out a niche with quality rather than price wars.

Aesthetic Variety: Though PABCO’s line isn’t huge, they have some standout aesthetic options. The most distinctive is the PABCO Cascade® shingle, which is cut in a diamond shape. When installed, Cascade shingles give a classic scalloped diamond pattern that you might see on historic Victorian homes or old churches – it’s one of the only products on the market that can achieve that look with asphalt. If you have a historic-style home or just want a head-turning roof design, Cascade is a unique option that practically no other brand offers (you’d otherwise have to go to metal shingles or specialty composites for a similar pattern). For more mainstream tastes, PABCO Premier and Prestige are architectural shingles with a wood-shake-inspired look, available in a range of modern colors. PABCO’s color palette tends to cover the bases: charcoals, weathered woods, browns, blacks, and grays. They also have some vibrant options like a deep forest green or a rich burgundy (names vary, but often there are a couple of bolder picks in their catalog). The Paramount Advantage is not only built tough but looks distinct – it has an “open tooth” design which creates a rugged, thick-cut appearance on the roof, almost like overlapping waves or scallops that cast deep shadows. This can add a lot of character to a roof, making it stand out from standard architectural shingle patterns. Additionally, PABCO offers the Solar Reflective Radiance® shingles mentioned earlier, which in terms of aesthetics are similar to their standard shingles but come in specialized lighter colors that meet cool roof requirements (often light grays, beiges, etc., with high reflectivity). One could say PABCO’s aesthetic niche is serving homeowners who want something a bit different from what all their neighbors have. Whether that’s the diamond pattern of Cascade or the bold cuts of Paramount, you won’t see those on every other house. Meanwhile, if you just want a reliable architectural shingle, the Premier/Prestige will look just as good and dimensional as any well-known brand’s equivalent. PABCO might not have 50 colors to choose from, but they ensure the styles they do offer are unique and visually appealing.

Ease of Installation: Installing PABCO shingles is generally similar to other architectural shingles, with a couple of caveats for their specialty products. The PABCO Premier, Prestige, and Paramount Advantage install like typical laminates – any qualified roofer will know the process: start with starter strips, nail 4-6 nails per shingle in the right area, stagger the courses, etc. Roofers have noted that PABCO shingles are consistent in size and quality, which makes the installation smooth (no fighting with irregular shingle lengths or broken pieces). The shingles have good sealant that bonds them in place once the sun warms them up, ensuring wind resistance. Because PABCO focuses on thicker shingles, a roofer might find the Prestige or Paramount slightly heavier to handle, but that’s akin to working with CertainTeed Landmark Premium or GAF ArmorShield – not a big deal for a pro. One thing to ensure is that your contractor is aware of any regional availability: PABCO is mostly distributed in the Western U.S. If you’re using them in, say, the Midwest or East, make sure you can source enough and any extras for repairs, since not every supplier carries them. Now, the Cascade diamond shingle is a special case. Its installation is a bit more complex because you’re creating a patterned look. Each shingle is a diamond shape that must be aligned properly to form the pattern. Roofers have to take their time to chalk lines and get the pattern perfect; it’s not hard, but it’s less forgiving of mistakes than a standard rectangular shingle. The roofer might need to cut more pieces to fit the pattern at hips, ridges, or valleys. Because of this, not all roofers have experience with Cascade. However, PABCO provides installation instructions for it, and a meticulous roofer can install it successfully – it just might take a bit more time and labor. As a homeowner, if you choose Cascade, you should pick a roofer who is patient and detail-oriented (or has done it before). For the installer, it’s almost like doing decorative tile work vs. plain tile – more planning but a stunning result. Other than that, PABCO shingles don’t present unusual challenges. Roofers in the know often respect PABCO, and if you have one of those roofers, they’ll likely be glad to work with a quality product. Always ensure the roofer follows manufacturer instructions (like how many nails, placement, etc.) to keep that warranty valid and performance up to spec. In summary, PABCO shingles install reliably, with the note that their specialty designs require a bit of extra installer finesse – something any seasoned roofer can handle with care.

Climate Performance: PABCO designs its products with the Western climate spectrum in mind, which ranges from rainy coastal areas to hot inland valleys and even mountain snow. In the Pacific Northwest (PNW), roofs face a lot of rain and often moss/algae growth. PABCO shingles have strong sealant to keep rain from driving under the shingles (they also promote using their PABCO® cap sheets and underlayments like PABCO® Universal Starter and PABCO® Edge for extra protection). Their shingles like Premier and Paramount are asphalt-rich and seal well, so water doesn’t easily penetrate. Additionally, PABCO includes algae-resistant granules in products likely to be used in PNW, mitigating algae and moss. For cold and snow: PABCO shingles can handle it, particularly the heavier ones. Many homes in the mountain regions of the West (think Sierra Nevada, Cascades) use PABCO with success. The key is proper attic ventilation and perhaps an ice shield, as with any roof, but the shingles themselves can bear snow load and cold temps. We don’t see a specific Class 4 hail rating mentioned in the snippet for PABCO, but absence in the Bob Vila text doesn’t mean they don’t have it; even if not, hail is less common on the West Coast, so class 4 might not have been a priority. If you are in a hail zone and considering PABCO, checking directly if Paramount Advantage or others are class 3 or 4 would be wise. In hot, sunny climates, PABCO’s Radiance shingles directly address that with reflective granules. But even their standard shingles hold up to UV – Washington state sees intense sun in summers and PABCO roofs there don’t notoriously fail from heat. They have granules to protect from UV and asphalt that can withstand thermal cycles. In windy areas, PABCO shingles are rated similarly to other laminates (110 mph standard, higher with enhancements). There aren’t a lot of hurricanes on the West Coast, but there are areas of high winds and PABCO seems to manage fine. One thing PABCO emphasizes is they make products to meet “unique needs of homeowners throughout the Western US”. That includes wildfire considerations – hence the Class A fire ratings which all their asphalt shingles achieve (especially important in California, where fire-rated roofs are often required). Because PABCO isn’t distributed everywhere, they may not have a lot of user feedback from the deep south or far northeast, but structurally and chemically there’s nothing that would limit them to only western climates. They should perform well in any North American climate, with the standard installation practices. If you live in an area where PABCO is available, you can trust that it’s formulated for durability in your weather. To sum up, PABCO provides dependable climate performance with special consideration for Western challenges (rain, moss, fire, sun), making it a smart choice if those align with your environment or if you simply want a high-quality shingle not everyone else on the block has.

BP (Building Products of Canada)

BP, short for Building Products of Canada, is a key player in the Canadian roofing market and also supplies parts of the northern U.S. Founded in 1925, BP has over a century of experience crafting products for tough Canadian weather. If you’re in Canada or the northern border states, you’ve likely heard of BP shingles such as Mystique or Dakota. Durability: BP designs its shingles explicitly to endure the harsh weather found in Canada and the northeastern United States. That means these shingles are built to stand up to cold winters, significant snowfall, cycles of freeze and thaw, as well as summer heat and occasional hail or heavy wind. BP’s lineup includes five main shingle products, all formulated with durability in mind. Their Mystique 42 is a double-layer laminated architectural shingle that’s a flagship product, offering solid durability with a strong fiberglass mat and robust tar line to seal against wind. The Mystique is named “42” because of its wider size (42 inches), which gives it a generous exposure and can make installation efficient. BP also offers Vangard 42 IR, which, as the “IR” suggests, is an Impact Resistant shingle – it carries a Class 4 impact rating (the highest) for hail. The Vangard is a heavy-duty laminated shingle, and that Class 4 means it’s tough as nails against hailstones, a big plus in places that get hailstorms. Another notable product is Manoir, a dual-layered designer laminated shingle that has a distinctive look resembling natural stone or slate, and its dual-layer construction makes it very tough as well. Manoir shingles, with their extra thickness, offer enhanced durability and wind resistance (and an attractive dimensional look). BP’s Dakota is their 3-tab offering – while 3-tabs are less durable than laminates, Dakota is still made to a 25-year spec and is used for economy projects; it’ll resist the elements decently but is more an entry-level roof. Across the board, BP shingles have Class A fire ratings and are made to seal well in cold and wet conditions. Many Canadian homeowners report BP roofs lasting a long time, provided they’re installed well. If one is looking for evidence of durability: BP’s shingles being prevalent in climates like Quebec or Ontario (with heavy snow, ice, and wind) attests to their rugged build. In short, BP has weather-tested durability, with certain products like Vangard and Manoir standing out for extra reinforcement (impact resistance and multi-layer strength).

Warranty: BP provides warranties similar to other major brands. Their laminated shingles like Mystique, Vangard, and Manoir come with a Limited Lifetime Warranty for the original owner (this is standard nowadays for architectural shingles). Typically, that includes an initial period of full coverage (for example, 15 years non-prorated is a figure some Canadian shingle warranties use, though we’d need to check BP’s exact numbers; it’s often around 10-15 years full coverage on defects, then prorated thereafter up to limited lifetime). Since BP products are geared towards harsh climates, their warranties also specifically cover things like wind damage and algae staining. For instance, if a shingle is rated for a certain wind (often 110 mph standard), the warranty will cover winds up to that level for a set time (say 5 years at 110 mph for a 3-tab, or 15 years at 130 mph for a laminate with extra nails – hypothetical example).  BP’s Algae Resistance: in some specifications we saw, it looked like perhaps not all BP shingles have algae-resistant granules (one RONA listing suggested Mystique is not algae resistant, but that could be a data quirk or maybe BP focuses less on algae in their standard product but could have an AR option). If algae resistance is important and you’re in a humid area, check if BP has an AR version or if products like Mystique inherently have some algae resistance. Warranties would typically give 5-10 years against algae staining if they include it. Since the Canadian climate in many areas is less conducive to algae than, say, Florida, BP might not emphasize this as much. Nonetheless, BP shingles are often treated with copper-containing granules (common for algae resistance) given they do mention being ready for Northeast US too (which can be humid). Warranty transfer: BP likely allows a one-time transfer within a certain period (maybe within 5 years of installation). This is typical and important if you think you might sell the house. In summary, BP’s warranties are comparable to other top brands – lifetime on the product, with specific term coverages for wind and other features, meant to reflect their confidence that the shingles can brave Canadian winters and beyond. Always check the specific warranty document, but you can rest assured BP isn’t skimping in this department; they know Canadian homeowners expect a solid promise for their investment.

Pricing: BP shingles tend to occupy the middle price range in the markets they serve. Being a Canadian manufacturer, BP shingles might be more cost-effective in Canada than imported U.S. brands, simply due to reduced transport and possibly favorable local pricing. For example, a BP Mystique roof in Canada might cost less than a CertainTeed Landmark roof, giving similar performance for a bit less money – that’s a scenario some homeowners have found. In the northern U.S. states near Canada, BP could also be competitively priced. BP’s Dakota 3-tab is a budget option, comparable to other 3-tabs in price (perhaps even cheaper if local). Mystique is the mainline architectural and is priced moderately – offering the architectural look at a reasonable cost. Manoir and Vangard, being specialty and double-layer, might cost more (they might be on the higher side, but still generally less than the most expensive U.S. luxury shingles). Given Bob Vila lists BP’s range as up to, they likely don’t have the ultra-costly offering that hits $$$$; even Manoir might be at most $$$. So BP offers good value, especially for Canadians. They deliver high-performance features (like Class 4 impact in Vangard) often at a standard architectural shingle price. For an American homeowner in the Northeast, if your roofer has access to BP, you might find the quote for a BP roof quite attractive against, say, GAF or OC – though availability can vary. One potential quirk: currency and market differences – if you’re in the U.S., BP might be a special order and could lose some of the cost advantage due to logistics. But in its home turf and adjacent areas, BP is positioned as a cost-effective quality choice. You aren’t necessarily paying extra for the Canadian toughness – it comes built-in.

Aesthetic Variety: BP’s shingle designs are created to complement the architectural styles common in their markets. The Mystique 42 is an architectural shingle with a broad exposure and shadow bands that create a rich, dimensional look. BP uses something called Weather-Tite™ technology in Mystique, which aside from performance, also gives a nice defined dragon’s tooth pattern (alternating high/low tabs) on the roof. The Mystique colors tend to be natural and subdued: think charcoal, brown, driftwood, slate, cedar tones, etc. They often have dual-tone granules to mimic the variation of real wood or stone. The Manoir is one of BP’s eye-catching styles – it’s designed to look like old-school European slate or stone roofing. Manoir shingles have a unique cut and dual-layer design that results in a scalloped, irregular pattern (not as pronounced as PABCO’s Cascade diamond, but somewhat similar vibe of an old world look). The colors for Manoir are curated to match that aesthetic: often deep grays, blacks, or earth tones that would resemble natural stone. If you want a roof that stands out with a historic flair, Manoir can deliver that. Vangard 42 IR likely looks similar to Mystique (since it’s also a laminated shingle, possibly just reinforced for impact) – it may come in a range of colors but perhaps with a focus on the ones popular in areas needing impact resistance (like neutral tones in hail regions). Dakota, the 3-tab, comes in numerous colors (many 3-tabs do), which are flat in appearance but if someone wants a simple, uniform look, it’s there – likely chosen for utility more than looks, but still available in various colors like black, brown, green, etc. BP also had a shingle called Everest (another architectural line) and maybe others not mentioned in Bob Vila. Everest is similar to Mystique, a laminate, with a different exposure cut; it might still be sold in certain regions. Aesthetic variety is reasonably broad – about five different product styles (3-tab, standard arch, impact arch, designer dual-layer, etc.) and within those, a palette of colors that BP updates according to trends. They might not have as many flamboyant color options as some U.S. lines, but you’ll find all the classic and modern favorites. One more interesting note: the Mystique uses shaded bands to create a three-dimensional look. This indicates that BP puts effort into the visual design of the granule layout, giving the shingles an attractive depth on your roof. Summary: BP provides the typical looks (3-tab and architectural) executed well, plus a distinctive designer style (Manoir) that can set your roof apart. If your home’s style is traditional, BP’s offerings will fit right in; if you want a unique upscale touch, Manoir does that in a way few asphalt shingles do.

Ease of Installation: Contractors in Canada are very familiar with BP shingles, and they generally find them straightforward to install. These shingles come in larger “42 inch” format, which means fewer shingles to nail per square and potentially a quicker installation once the crew is used to them. The larger size also means a wider exposure (often around 5-5/8 inches or so), which can mean fewer rows on the roof – again a slight time saver. BP’s Weather-Tite™ technology in shingles like Mystique refers to a two-sealant stripe system that they use; from an installation standpoint, that means once the shingle is nailed and the sun activates those adhesive strips, the shingles stick down very well, which is great for wind resistance, but the roofer doesn’t have to do anything special to activate it (just normal warm weather or sun). The nailing area on BP laminates is clear and standard – roofers need to ensure they hit through the double layer portion (common with all laminates). There’s no fancy added strip like OC’s SureNail, but that’s okay if nailed correctly. One possible consideration is temperature: BP shingles are engineered for cold weather tolerance, which likely also means their asphalt may be a bit stiffer in mild temperatures (to survive cold without cracking, the formulation might be slightly stiffer at room temp). Roofers might notice they are a tad firmer to cut or bend in moderate weather compared to a very soft asphalt shingle. However, this stiffness is usually not an issue unless you’re in near-freezing weather trying to install (in which case all shingles are a pain). In summer, they soften up nicely for easy cutting. A plus: BP 3-tabs (Dakota) are known for having a solid build, which actually makes them less floppy when aligning on the roof. For the laminated ones, alignment is easy due to factory-applied guiding lines. Another aspect is availability of installers: In places like New England or the Great Lakes, not every roofer may be used to BP, since brands like GAF, OC, CertainTeed dominate. But any competent roofer can install BP – the methods are no different than what they know. It’s asphalt shingles after all. If anything, you’ll want to ensure your contractor reads BP’s specific requirements for things like nails per shingle in high wind areas or use of starter strip and hip/ridge caps (BP likely recommends their own, but equivalents work if done properly). The Manoir shingles, being dual-layer and of unique cut, might require a bit more attention to the pattern and matching of pieces, similar to how CertainTeed’s luxury shingles do. But it’s still a repeating pattern shingle, easier than something like PABCO’s diamond. In conclusion, BP shingles pose no difficulties beyond the ordinary. They’re designed to be installed efficiently (large format) and securely (good sealing). A roofer might comment that BP makes a “solid shingle” when nailing it, as it doesn’t crumble or tear easily. For you as a homeowner, that translates to a smooth installation and a roof that’s well-prepared for the next blizzard or thunderstorm.

Climate Performance: This is where BP really earns its stripes. Canadian weather can be unforgiving, and BP shingles are purpose-built to handle it. In frigid temperatures and heavy snow, a BP roof holds strong. These shingles are formulated to remain flexible enough to avoid cracking in sub-zero cold, yet rigid enough to support snow and ice. The Manoir’s dual layers would, for instance, add extra protection against ice dams (coupled with proper underlayment). We see that all BP shingles are designed to endure harsh weather of Canada, which includes not just cold, but also things like significant temperature swings. Many parts of Canada see freeze-thaw cycles in spring and fall, which can stress materials – BP shingles’ construction and strong sealant help prevent water infiltration during those cycles. For wind, BP’s laminated shingles have good wind warranties (often up to 180 km/h which is ~110 mph, and possibly higher with extra nails). They’ll stand up to strong winter storms or coastal winds in the Maritimes or Great Lakes squalls. For hail, having the Vangard 42 IR with Class 4 impact rating is a big plus. That indicates it’s tested to handle hailstones without cracking – ideal for the hail-prone Prairie provinces or upper Midwest states. If you live somewhere that occasionally gets hail, opting for Vangard could be wise. Rain and moisture: Eastern Canada and Northeast US can see heavy rains (and Vancouver area sees near-constant drizzle in seasons). BP shingles seal tightly and have features like that Weather-Tite double sealant to keep wind-driven rain from getting under. They also likely design their shingles to dry out well (good roof ventilation helps too) to prevent issues. Heat and sun: While Canada is cold, summers can be hot, and the sun at high latitudes can be intense on long summer days. BP shingles use UV-resistant granules and tough asphalt, so they handle summer heat just fine. In fact, BP has certain colors that qualify as cool roof options (lighter shades that reflect more sunlight, perhaps not explicitly mentioned but likely available given modern standards). If you were to use BP in a very hot climate (say someone in Florida considering BP), it would likely perform adequately too, but BP doesn’t market there widely. In humid climates: The Northeastern US can be humid in summer; algae can grow. If BP’s standard shingles don’t inherently have algae-resistant granules, a homeowner might need to keep an eye out. However, it’s likely they do include some algae protection on Mystique and others, just maybe not as heavily advertised as others. If not, occasional roof washing might be needed after many years. But in practice, Canadian roofs don’t often get the severe algae that, say, Gulf Coast roofs do, so BP might have determined heavy copper granules not as critical for their primary market (this is speculation; they might well have algae tech in there). Lastly, fire performance: Not climate, but environmental – BP shingles are all Class A fire rated (when installed with proper underlayment), which is good in case of wildfires or stray embers, an important factor in some forested areas. All considered, BP is a weather warrior brand. If your home needs to brave bitter winters, strong winds, or hailstorms, BP has a solution tailor-made. They literally design with Canadian winters in mind, which arguably sets a high bar for toughness. So, for homeowners in the northern tier looking for reliability through every season, BP shingles are a compelling option.

Conclusion: Choosing the Right Shingle for Your Home

All these leading brands – Atlas, Owens Corning, TAMKO, GAF, CertainTeed, IKO, PABCO, and BP – produce quality asphalt shingles that can protect and beautify your home. However, each has its own strengths and ideal use-cases:

• If you live in a storm-prone or humid area and want top-notch algae and wind protection, Atlas shingles (with lifetime algae resistance and high wind/hail ratings) are a strong contender.
• If you’re looking for a well-rounded, widely available shingle with a great blend of performance and price, Owens Corning provides reliable durability (thanks to SureNail® tech) and plenty of style at a fair cost.
• For those on a budget who still want a beautiful architectural roof, TAMKO offers affordability and vibrant color choices, and their new high-wind Titan XT line shows they can compete on performance too.
• If you prefer the industry heavyweight with extensive options and proven track record, GAF is hard to beat. From the best-selling Timberline series (America’s #1 shingle) to luxury designs, GAF combines innovation (like the no-limit wind warranty) with broad contractor support.
• When only the premium will do and you want a roof that’s the talk of the neighborhood, CertainTeed’s high-quality shingles deliver longevity and luxury looks – albeit at a higher price. They boast some of the toughest, best-regarded shingles and warranties around.
• If you value a shingle built for tough winters or want great performance per dollar, IKO could be your pick. Especially in cold or hail-prone regions, IKO’s heavy-duty lines (like Nordic or Dynasty) provide top-tier protection without top-tier cost.
• For homeowners in the Western U.S. (or anyone seeking something a bit different), PABCO offers unique styles like the diamond-shaped Cascade and an emphasis on quality over quantity in their product line. You get a durable, distinctive roof – just ensure your contractor is familiar with the brand.
• And if you’re in Canada or the northern states, BP shingles are tailored for your climate. They might not be as flashy in marketing, but they are engineered to last through brutal winters and come out strong. With options like Class 4 impact-rated shingles for hail and dual-layer designs for style and strength, BP is a smart, climate-savvy choice.

In making your decision, consider what matters most to you. Is it the durability to withstand specific weather threats? The peace of mind of a long warranty? A price that fits your budget? Or perhaps the aesthetic that will make you fall in love with your home every time you see it? Also, think about the installer’s input – a trusted roofer may have experience with certain brands and can offer insight into how a shingle performs and lasts in your local area. All these brands have reputable products; there isn’t a “bad” choice among them, but there is a best choice for your particular needs.

No matter which brand you lean toward, remember a few final tips: always use a certified or experienced roofer, ensure your attic has proper ventilation (this greatly affects shingle life), and consider the whole roofing system (underlayment, ventilation, flashings) – not just the shingles. A great shingle from Atlas, Owens Corning, Tamko, GAF, CertainTeed, IKO, PABCO, or BP will do its job, especially when installed correctly and paired with the right accessories and maintenance.

By weighing the factors detailed in this comparison, you’re well on your way to selecting an asphalt shingle that will protect your home beautifully for many years to come. Here’s to a sturdy, stunning roof over your head!